U.S. District Judge Timothy DeGiusti, a federal judge, has granted an injunction Friday that prohibits the government from enforcing the federal health care law’s requirement that insurance coverage include access to the morning-after pill and similar contraceptives on almost 200 religious organizations that have filed a class-action lawsuit to block the mandate.
The preliminary injunction will prevent the government from enforcing the mandate as the religious groups’ lawsuit makes its way through the legal system. The suit was filed in October on behalf of 187 ministries that provide their employees with health benefits through GuideStone Financial Resources, the health benefits arm of the Southern Baptist Convention. In the lawsuit, the ministries object to providing four out of 20 Food and Drug Administration-approved contraceptives, including the morning-after pill which they allege may cause early abortions.
In his 16-page decision, DeGiusti said the ministries have the right to challenge the health care law’s contraceptive mandate and that an injunction is needed to prevent the federal government from enforcing it on them. The suit is similar to one filed in Oklahoma City last year by Hobby Lobby Stores which calls itself a “biblically founded business.” That lawsuit also challenges the mandate that employers provide coverage for the morning-after pill and similar drugs. In July, a federal judge granted a temporary exemption to the Oklahoma City based arts and crafts chain, a ruling the government has appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. Hobby Lobby’s lawsuit claims the government mandate is forcing the Christian family that owns the chain “to violate their deeply held religious beliefs under threat of heavy fines, penalties and lawsuits.” Failure to provide the drugs in the company’s health insurance plan could lead to fines up to $1.3 million a day the company said. Hobby Lobby’s owners have said they believe life begins at conception and they oppose birth control methods that can prevent implantation of a fertilized egg in the uterus such as an intrauterine device or forms of emergency contraception.
DeGiusti repeatedly referred to the Hobby Lobby case in his ruling and said the ministries who refuse to provide the contraceptives also “face substantial financial penalties, and their refusal will cause a substantial financial loss to GuideStone if it excludes non-exempt, non-compliant organizations from the GuideStone plan.” The ruling states, “Here, as in Hobby Lobby, the court finds that plaintiffs have made a threshold showing of a substantial burden, and , thus, a likelihood of success.”
The decision was praised by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty in Washington which represents Hobby Lobby and GuideStone in their separate lawsuits. “This is an overwhelming victory for GuideStone and the nearly 200 plaintiffs in this class-action lawsuit,” attorney Adele Keim said in a statement. “Today’s ruling will allow hundreds of Baptist ministries to continue preaching the gospel and serving the poor this Christmas, without laboring under the threat of massive fines.”
