African-American Missionaries to Jamaica, to Hawaii, to Indians…. and the Founding of Kansas City

Who were the first African American missionaries sent out from the United States?

George Lisle, the first ordained African American, went in 1782 to Jamaica with other freed slaves to begin a Baptist Mission.

John Marrant, a free black from New York City, went to Newfoundland and preached to “a great number of Indians and white people” at Green’s Harbour.

John Marrant later preached the Gospel to Tribes of Cherokee, Creek, Catawar and Housaw.

The African Methodist Episcopal denomination, founded in 1816 by Richard Allen, sent missionaries to Haiti, San Domingo and Africa.

In 1823, Betsey Stockton, a young African American woman, sailed with the second group of missionaries from New Haven, Connecticut, to Hawaii.

In 1821, Lott Cary and Colin Teaque were sent to Liberia, being the first missionaries sent out by an African American organization, the Richmond African Baptist Missionary Society.

In 1786,John Stewart, a free black of mixed race, was born in Powhatten County, Virginia.

As a young man, John Stewartlearned the blue-dying trade. He took his life savings and began traveling, intending to join his family in Tennessee, but was robbed along the way.

Arriving destitute and depressed in Marietta, Ohio, John Stewartbegan to drink.

His story is recorded in Joseph Mitchell’s book,The Missionary Pioneer, or A Brief Memoir of the Life, Labours, and Death of John Stewart, (Man of Colour,) Founder, under God of the Mission among the Wyandotts at Upper Sandusky, Ohio (New-York: printed by J. C. Totten, 1827):

“The loss of his property, the distance from his friends, the idea of poverty and disgrace, together with the wretched situation of his mind on account of his soul’s affairs, brought him to shocking determination that he would immediately take measures to hasten his dissolution.

And for this purpose he forthwith commenced a course of excessive drinking in a public house.

This was continued until his nerves became much affected, his hands trembled so it was difficult for him to feed himself.”

John Stewart tried to straighten out his life and worked in the country making sugar, as Thelma R. Marsh wrote in Moccasin Trails to the Cross (United Methodist Church, 1st edition, 1974):

“Stewart…return to town, where, contrary to the most solemn vows and promises, which he had previously made to forsake sin and seek the Lord…

An occurrence here took place which much alarmed him: an intimate companion of his was suddenly called by death from time to eternity.

With this individual he had made an appointment to spend one more night in sin; but death interfered and disappointed them both.

Stewart’s convictions of mind were thereupon greatly increased, and he began to despair of ever obtaining mercy.”

The book, John Stewart-Missionary Pioneer(published 1827), stated:

“One day while wandering along the banks of the Ohio, bewailing his wretched and undone condition, the arch enemy of souls suggested to him a remedy, which was to terminate the miseries he endured by leaping into the deep, and thereby putting an end to his existence.

To this suggestion, he at first felt a disposition to yield, but his attention was arrested by a voice, which he thought called him by name; when on looking around he could see no person, whereupon he desisted from the further prosecution of the desperate project…

Then it was that the Lord was pleased to reveal his mercy and pardoning love to his fainting soul, causing him to burst forth from his closet in raptures of unspeakable joy, declaring what the Lord had done for his poor soul!…

…There being no Baptist church near…as he walked out one evening he heard the sound of singing and praying proceeding from a house at no great distance. It proved to be a Methodist prayer meeting.

His prejudices at first forbade his going in but curiosity prompted him to venture a little nearer, and at length he resolved to enter and make known his case, which he did.”

The book, John Stewart-Missionary Pioneer (1827), continued:

“Soon after this he attended a Camp Meeting, here he remained for sometime with a heavy heart…

…He at length resolved…by taking a place among the mourners of the assembly, where he lay deploring his case all night, even until the break of day, at which time ‘the sun of righteousness’ broke into his dark bewildered soul…

He heard a sound which much alarmed him: and a voice (as he thought) said to him-

‘Thou shalt declare my counsel faithfully’ at the same time a view seemed to open to him in a Northwest direction, and a strong impression was made on his mind, that he must go out that course into the world to declare the counsel of God…

…He set out without credentials, directions of the way, money or bread, crossed the Muskingum River for the first time, and traveled a northwest course, not knowing whither he went…

He was frequently informed would lead him into the Indian country on the Sandusky River, some times with, sometimes without a road, without a pilot, without fireworks, sometimes wading the waters and swimming the rivers.”

Abraham J. Baughman wrote in Past and Present of Wyandot County, Ohio: a record of settlement(Chicago: The S.J. Clark Publishing Company, 1913, Volume 1,  page 39-43):

“At Pipetown was a considerable body of Delawares…

At this place Stewart stopped, but as the Indians were preparing for a great dance they paid but little attention to him…

Stewart took out his hymn book and began to sing.

He, as is usual with many of his race, had a most melodious voice, and as a result of his effort the Indians present were charmed and awed into perfect silence.

When he ceased. Johnny-cake said in broken English, ‘Sing more.’

He then asked if there was any person present who could interpret for him; when old Lyons, who called himself one hundred and sixty years old (for he counted the summer a year and the winter a year) came forward. Stewart talked to them…”

John Stewart made it to the tribe of Wyandots, who were called by the French“Huron.”

They previously had treaties with the French during the French and Indian Wars 1754-1763, and helped found Detroit.

They later made treaties with the British during Revolutionary War and the War of 1812.

John Stewart reached the home of Indian William Walker, Sr., who first believed Stewart to be a run-away slave.

Stewart convinced him that he had come to bring the gospel of Jesus Christ to the children of the forest.

Realizing that Stewart could not speak the Wyandot language, William Walkersent him to Jonathan Pointer, a black man who in his youth had been kidnapped by the Wyandots, adopted into their tribe and had learned the Wyandot language.

Pointer served as interpreter for Stewart when he preached, but not wanting his friends to think that he believed, Pointer ended each interpretation with a remark “These are his words, not mine” or “That’s what the preacher says, but I don’t believe it.”

Later, Pointer converted.

One of John Stewart’s first Wyandot converts was Chief Between-the-Logs, who years before in a drunken fit had killed his wife, only to wake up in horror at what he had done.

Chief Between-the-Logs gave the history:

“Our fathers had religion of their own. They served God and were happy. That was before the White Man came. They worshiped with feasts and sacrifices, dances and rattles. They did what they thought was right.

Our parents wished us to do good and they used to make us do good, and would sometimes correct us for doing evil…

…But a great while ago the French sent us a book by the Roman Priest and we listened to him… We did what he told us… At last he went away.

Then we returned to our fathers’ religion again. But then the Seneca prophet came and he said that he had talked to the Great Spirit, and he was told what the Indian ought to do.

We listened to him and many followed him. But we found that he told us not to do things and then he did those things himself. So we were deceived…

Again we took up the religion of our fathers. But then the Shawnee prophet arose. We heard him and some of us followed him for awhile, but we had been deceived so often that we watched him very closely, and soon found that he was like all the rest so we left him also.”

Chief Between-the-Logscontinued:

“Then there was war between our fathers and the President and King George…

By the time the war was over we were all scattered and many killed and died. Our chiefs thought to get the nation together again.

Then the Black Man, Stewart, our brother here (pointed to Stewart) came to us and told us he was sent by the Great Spirit to tell us the true and good way.

But we thought he was like all the rest – that he too wanted to cheat us and get our money and land from us.

He told us of our sins and that drinking was ruining us and that the Great Spirit was angry with us. He said that we must leave off these things.

But we treated him ill and gave him little to eat, and trampled on him and were jealous of him for a whole year.

Then we attended his meeting in the council house. We could find no fault with him.

The Great Spirit came upon us so that all cried aloud. Some clapped their hands, some ran away, and some were angry. We held our meetings all night, sometimes singing, sometimes praying.

By now we were convinced that God had sent him to us. Stewart is a good man.”

Eventually, the entire tribe ofWyandots converted to Christianity.

In 1821, the Methodist Conference sent Rev. James B. Finley to start the mission school at Upper Sandusky.

John Stewart worked with him and taught a Bible class at the Big Springs Reserve.

Rev. James B. Finley recorded the missionary work of John Stewart with the Wyandots in the History of the Wyandot Mission (Cincinnati: Methodist Book Concern).

The State of Ohio also published a record of John Stewart’s missionary work in Henry Howe’s Historical Collections of Ohio (published by The Laning Printing Co., Norwalk, OH, 1896, Volume 2).

John Stewart died December 18, 1823, with his last words, “Be Faithful.”

In 1830, a Democrat-controlled Congress hurriedly passed the Indian Removal Act, signed by Democrat President Andrew Jackson, and carried out by Democrat President Martin Van Buren.

This forced the removal of over 16,000 Native Americans:

Cherokee from Georgia, the Carolinas and Tennessee;

Muscogee (Creek) from Alabama, Georgia, and Florida;

Seminole from Florida;

Chickasaw from Mississippi, Alabama, Tennessee; and

Choctaw from Alabama and Louisiana.

Carried out by the Federal Government in the freezing winter, over 4,000 died in what is referred to at theTrail of Tears.

The Wyandots were the last tribe to leave Ohio in 1843.

The year before English authorCharles Dickens had traveled through Ohio by stage coach from Columbus to Sandusky City, where he boarded a steamer for Buffalo.

In his American Notes, Charles Dickens wrote:

“At length…a few feeble lights appeared in the distance… an Indian village, where we were to stay till morning… It is a settlement of Wyandot Indians who inhabit this place.

Among the company was a mild old gentleman (Col. John Johnston), who had been for many years employed by the United States government in conducting negotiations with the Indians…

and who had just concluded a treaty with these people by which they bound themselves, in consideration of a certain annual sum, to remove next year to some land provided for them west of the Mississippi and a little way beyond St. Louis…

…He gave me a moving account of their strong attachment to the familiar scenes of their infancy, and in particular to the burial places of their kindred, and of their great reluctance to leave them.

He had witnessed many such removals, and always with pain.”

William Walker, Sr., theWyandots’ principal chief, had been able to secure land on the border between Missouri and Kansas.

They emigrated and founded the City of Wyandotte, which was later renamed Kansas City.